
A Short Overview of California Indian History
by Professor Edward Castillo, Professor of History,
Sonoma State University
REGIONAL LIFEWAYS
One manner in which we can seek to understand aboriginal
California Indian cultures is to
look at the tribes inhabiting similar climatic and ecological zones. What emerges from this approach
is a remarkable similarity in material
aspects of the many different tribes inhabiting those territories.
Generally speaking technologies
and materials used to manufacture tools, homes and storage containers show
great similarity. Hunting, trapping and fishing technologies also are shared across tribal lines terrain,
available water plants and animals affected the density of populations,
settlement patterns as each tribe adjusted to its environment.
NORTHWEST
This area would include the Tolowa, Shasta, Karok, Yurok,
Hupa, Whilikut, Chilula, Chimarike and Wiyot tribes. The distinctive northern
rainforest environment encouraged these tribes to establish their villages
along the many rivers, lagoons and coastal bays that dotted their landscape.
While this territory was crisscrossed with thousands of trails, the most
efficient form of transportation was the dugout canoe used to travel up and
down rivers and cross the wider and deeper ones such as the Klamath. These
tribes used the great coast Redwood trees for the manufacture of their boats
and houses. Redwoods were cleverly
felled by burning at the base and then split with elkhorn wedges. Redwood and
sometimes cedar planks were used to construct rectangular gabled homes. Baskets
in a variety of designs were manufactured in with the twined technique only.
Many of these arts survived into the twentieth century and traditional skills
have enjoyed a great renaissance in the past twenty years.
The elaborate ritual life of these tribes featured a World Renewal ceremony held each fall in the largest villages. Sponsored by the wealthiest men in the communities, the ceremony's purpose was to prevent future natural catastrophes such as earthquakes, floods or failure of acorn crop or a poor salmon run. Supplication to supernatural spirits. Because
such disasters directly threaten the community, great attention to detail and
the utmost solemnity accompanied such ceremonies. This and other traditional
rituals continue to be practiced, despite the grinding poverty that plagues
many of these groups.
These tribes were governed by the most wealthy and powerful
lineage leaders. The great emphasis on wealth found in these cultures is
reflected in the emphasis on private ownership of food resources such as oak
groves and fishing areas.
NORTHEAST
This region included the Modoc, Achumawi, and Atsugewi tribes. The western portion of this territory was rich in acorn and Salmon. Further to the East, the climate changes from mountainous to a high desert type of topography. Here food resources were grass seeds, tuber berries along with rabbit and deer.
These Indians found tule to be a useful source of both food (the rootbulb is consumed) and a convenient material when laced together to form floor mats and structure covering. Volcanic mountains in the Western portion of their territory supplied the valuable trade commodity obsidian. The Social-political organization of these peoples was independent but connected to their neighbors by marriage ties. Following contact, the Achumawi and Atsuguewi suffered a tremendous population decline due to vigilante violence and respiratory diseases. The Modocs spectacular 1872 resistance to removal to the Oregon territory was the last heroic military defense
of native sovereignty in 19th century California Indian History.
Some surviving Northeast tribesmen received public land
allotments around the turn of the century. The XL Rancheria was established for
some of these Indians in 1938. Tragically the surviving Modocs were exiled to
either Oregon or Oklahoma.
CENTRAL CALIFORNIA
This vast territory includes: Bear River, Mattale, Lassick,
Nogatl, Wintun, Yana, Yahi, Maidu, Wintun, Sinkyone, Wailaki, Kato, Yuki, Pomo,
Lake Miwok, Wappo, Coast Miwok, Interior Miwok, Wappo, Coast Miwok, Interior
Miwok, Monache, Yokuts, Costanoan, Esselen, Salinan and Tubatulabal tribes.
Vast differences exists between the coastal peoples, nearby mountain range territories, from those living in the vast central valleys and on the slopes of the Sierra Nevada. Nevertheless, all of these tribes enjoyed an abundance of acorn and salmon that could be readily obtained in the waterways north of Monterey Bay. Deer, elk, antelope and rabbit were available
elsewhere in vast quantities.
In this region basketry reached the height of greatest variety. Perhaps the Pomo basket makers created the most elaborate versions of this art. Both coiled and twine type baskets were produced throughout the region. Fortunately basket making survived the years of suppression of native arts and culture to once again become one of the most important
culturally defining element for Indians in this region.
Common in this area was the semi-subterranean roundhouse
where elaborate Kuksu dances were held in the past and continue to this day.
These rituals assure the renewal of the world's natural foods both plant and
animal. Despite differences, between tribes, these rituals share similar
purposes.
Like everywhere else, in California, villages were fiercely
independent and governed internally, The abundant food supply allowed for the
establishment of villages of up to 1000 individuals, including craft
specialists who produced specific objects and goods for a living. In smaller
communities, each family produced all that was necessary for survival.
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
Southern California presents a varied and somewhat unique
region of the state. Beginning in the north, tribes found in this area are the
Chumash, Alliklik, Kitanemuk, Serrano, Gabrielino, Luiseno, Cahuilla and the
Kumeyaay. The landmass and climate varied considerably from the windswept
offshore channelIslands that were principally inhabited by Chumash speaking
peoples. Communication with their mainland neighbors was by large and graceful
planked canoes powered by double paddle ores.
These vessels were called "Tomols" and
manufactured by a secretive guild of craftsmen. They could carry hundreds of
pounds of trade goods and up to a dozen passengers. Like their northern neighbors,
the Tactic speaking peoples of San Nicholas and Santa Catalina Islands built
planked canoes and actively traded rich marine resources with mainland villages
and tribes.
Shoreline communities enjoyed the rich animal and faunal
life of ocean, bays and wetlands environments. Interior tribes like the
Serrano, Luiseno, Cahuilla, and Kumeyaay shared an environment rich in Sonoran
life zone featuring vast quantities of rabbit, deer and an abundance of acorn,
seeds and native grasses. At the higher elevations Desert Bighorn sheep were
hunted.
Villages varied in size from poor desert communities with villages of as little as 100 people to the teaming Chumash villages with over a thousand inhabitants. Conical homes of arroweed, tule or croton were common, while whale bone structures could be found on the coast and nearby Channel Islands. Interior groups manufactured clay storage vessels sometimes
decorated with paint. Baskets were everywhere manufactured with unique designs.
Catalina Island possessed a soapstone or steatite quarry.
This unique stone was soft and could easily be carved with cutting tools and
shaped into vessels, pipes and cooking slabs.
Each tribe and community had a chieftain, sometimes females,
whose duty it was to organize community events and settle conflicts among their
followers. This leader was usually assisted by a crier or assistant, Shaman or
Indian doctors were known everywhere and greatly respected.
The ritual use of the hallucinogen jimsonweed (Datura
meteloides) was primarily in male puberty rituals. Like other California Indian
communities, society was divided into three classes, the elite, a middle class
and finally a less successful lower class. These robust peoples were among the
first to encounter the strangers who would change their world forever.
HISTORY
The Spanish entrada into Alta California was the last great
expansions of Spain's vastly over extended empire in North America. Massive
Indian revolts among the Pueblo Indians of the Rio Grande in the late 17th
century provided the Franciscan padres with an argument to establish missions
relatively free from colonial settlers. Thus California and its Spanish
Colonization would be different from earlier efforts to simultaneously
introduce missionaries and colonists in their world conquest schemes. Organized
by the driven Franciscan administrator Junipero Serra and military authorities
under Gaspar de Portola, they journeyed to San Diego in 1769 to establish the
first of 21 coastal missions.
Despite romantic portraits of California missions they were
essentially coercive religious, labor camps organized primarily to benefit the
colonizers. The overall plan was to first militarily intimidate the local
Indians with armed Spanish soldiers who always accompanied
the Franciscans in their missionary efforts. At the same time the newcomers
introduced domestic stock animals that gobbled up native foods and undermined
the free or "gentile" tribes efforts to remain economically
independent.
A well established pattern of bribes, intimidation and the expected onslaught of European diseases insured experienced missionaries that eventually desperate parents of sick and dying children and many elders would prompt frightened Indian families to seek assistance from the newcomers who seemed to be immune to the horrible diseases that overwhelmed Indians. The missions were authorized by the crown to "convert" the Indians in a ten-year period. Thereafter they were supposed to surrender their control over the missions' livestock, fields, orchards and building to the Indians. But the padres never achieved this goal and the lands and wealth was stolen from
the Indians.
Epidemic diseases proved to be the most significant factor
in colonial efforts to overcome native resistance. Soon after the arrival of
Spanish colonists, new diseases appeared among the tribes in close proximity
Spanish missions. Scientific studies of demographic trends during this period
indicate the Indians of the America's did not possess any natural immunity to
introduced European diseases.
Maladies such as smallpox, syphilis, diphtheria and even
children's' ailments such as chickenpox and measles caused untold suffering and
death among Indians near the Spanish centers of population. Even before the
outbreak of epidemics, a general population decline was recorded that can be
attributed to the unhygienic environment of colonial population centers. A
series of murderous epidemic diseases swept over the terrified mission Indian
populations.
Beginning in 1777 a voracious epidemic likely associated with a water born bacterial infection devastated Santa Clara Valley Costanoan children. Again children were the primary victims of a second epidemic of pneumonia and diphtheria expended from Monterey to Los Angeles was recorded in 1802. By far the worst of these terrifying epidemics began in 1806 and killed thousands of Indian children and adults. It has been identified as
measles and attacked Indian populations from San Francisco to the central coast
settlement of Santa Barbara.
Sadly, the missionary practice of forcibly separating Indian
children from their parents and incarcerating children from the age of six in
filthy and disease ridden gender barracks most likely increased the suffering
and death of above mentioned epidemics. Excessive manual labor demands of the
missionaries and poor nutrition probably contributed to the Indians inability
to resist such infections. Less easily measured damage to mission Indian tribes
occurred as they vainly struggled to understand the biological tragedy that was
overwhelming them. Faith in their traditional shaman suffered when native
efforts were ineffective in stemming the tide of misery, suffering and death
that life in the missions resulted in.
With monotonous regularity, missionaries and other colonial officials reported upon the massive death and poor health of their Indian laborers. Pioneering demographer Sherburne F. Cook conducted exhaustive studies and concluded that perhaps as much as 60% of the population decline of mission Indians was due to introduced diseases.
NATIVE RESISTANCE
The unrelenting labor demands, forced separation of children
from their parents and unending physical coercion that characterized the life
of Indians under padre's authority resulted in several well-documented forms of
Indian resistance. Within the missions, the so-called "converts"
continued to surreptitiously worship their old deities as well as conduct
native dances and rituals in secret. By far the most frequent form of mission
Indian resistance was fugativism.
While thousands of the 81,586 baptized Indians temporarily
fled their missions, more that one out of 24 successfully escaped the
plantation like mission labor camps. Many Mission Indians viewed the padres as
powerful witches who could only be neutralized by assassination. Consequently,
several assassinations occurred.
At Mission San Miguel in the year of 1801 three padres were poisoned, one of
whom died as a result. Four years later another San Miguel Yokut male attempted
to stone a padre to death,
In 1804, a San Diego Padre was poisoned by his personal cook
Costanoan Indians at Mission Santa Cruz, in 1812, killed a padre for
introducing a new instrument of torture which he unwisely announced he planned
to use on some luckless neophytes awaiting a beating. Few contemporaries
Americans know of the widespread
armed revolts precipitated by Mission Indians against colonial authorities. The
Kumeyaay of San Diego launched two serious military assaults against the
missionaries and their military escorts within five weeks of their arrival in
1769.
Desperate to stop an ugly pattern of sexual assaults, the Kumeyaay utterly destroyed Mission San Diego and killed the local padre in 1775. Quechan and Mohave Indians along the Colorado River to the east destroyed two missions, killed four missionaries and numerous other colonists in a spectacular uprising in 1781. This last rebellion permanently denied the
only overland route into Alta California from Northern New Spain (Mexico) to
Spanish authorities.
Military efforts to reopen the road and punish the Indians
were met with utter failure. The last great mission Indian revolt occurred in
1824 when disenchanted Chumash Indians violently overthrew mission control at
Santa Barbara, Santa Ynez and La Purisima. Santa Barbara was sacked and
abandoned while Santa Ynez Chumash torched 3/4 of the buildings before fleeing.
Defiant Chumash at La Purisima in fact seized that mission and fought a pitched
battle with colonial troops while a significant number of other Chumash escaped
deep into the interior of the Southern San Joaquin Valley. After 1810 a growing
number of guerrilla bands evolved in the interior when fugitive mission Indians
allied with interior tribes and villages. Mounted on horses and using modern
weapons, they began raiding mission livestock and fighting colonial military
forces.
The impact of the mission system on the many coastal tribes
was devastating. Missionaries required tribes to abandon their aboriginal
territories and live in filthy, disease ridden and crowded labor camps. Massive
herds on introduced stock animals and new seed crops soon crowded out
aboriginal game animals and native plants. Feral hogs ate tons of raw acorns,
depriving even the non-missionized tribes in the interior of a significant
amount of aboriginal protein.
Murderous waves of epidemic diseases swept over the terrified Mission Indian tribes resulting in massive suffering and death for thousands of native men, women and children. The short life expectancy of mission Indians prompted missionaries to vigorously pursue runaways and coerce interior tribes into supplying more and more laborers for the padres. Missionary
activities therefore thoroughly disrupted not only coastal tribes, but also
their demand for healthy laborers seriously impacted adjacent interior tribes.
Finally by 1836 the Mexican Republic forcibly stripped the
padres of the power to coerce labor from the Indians and the mission rapidly
collapsed. About 100,000 or nearly a third of the aboriginal population of California
died as a direct consequence of the missions of California.
Despite the devastating population decline suffered by tribes in whose territories missions had been established, many managed to maintain tribal cohesion. After 1800, most mission populations were a hodgepodge of different tribes speaking a multiplicity of languages. Because many Indians refused to learn or feigned ignorance of the Spanish language,
missionaries appointed labor overseers from each tribe to direct work crews.
Such practical policies kept tribesmen from losing culturally distinct
identity. Further evidence of cultural persistence was the practice of tribes
maintaining separate housing in multi-tribal Indian villages built next to the
missions. Finally, many former mission Indians continued to speak their native
languages and provide researchers with detailed ethnographic and linguistic
data well into the 20th century.
INDIANS AND THE MEXICAN REPUBLIC
In 1823 the Spanish Flag was replaced by that of the Mexican Republic. Little immediate change in personal or Indian policy occurred. However, the independence government was decidedly anti-clerical and the growing body of colonial leaders deeply resented the monopoly of Indian lands and the unpaid Indian labor enjoyed by the Franciscans. While no land
grants to the colonists had occurred under Spanish rule, some 25 grazing
permits or concessions had been issued to colonial citizens.
This was the beginning of the dispossession of tribal lands
by colonial authorities. The vast plantation like missions claimed about 1/6 of
the present territory of the state. But legal title to these lands was assigned
to the Spanish crown. The missions were only suppose to last 10 years, after
which the developed estates were to be distributed to surviving mission
Indians. It was assumed that the Indians would evolve into hardworking,
tax-paying citizens of Mexico.
But the missionaries kept coming up with excuses why they
should not surrender the rich pastoral and agrarian empire they had erected
with the lands, resources and hard labor of mission Indians. The Mexican
Republic's 1824 constitution declared Indians to be citizens with rights to
both vote and hold public office. Despite this liberal declaration, Indians
throughout the republic continued to be treated as slaves.
COLLAPSE OF THE MISSION SYSTEM
In actual practice, the new government gave 51 land grants to its colonial citizens between 1824 and 1834. These lands actually
belonged to various tribes then incarcerated in nearby missions. These actions
just increased the lust for more Indian lands by a growing body of colonial
ranchers.
There followed a growing chorus of demands that the missionaries surrender their monopoly on Indian labor and "free" the Indians. The sincerity those sentiments should be seriously doubted. The power of this class prevailed and between 1834-36 the government revoked the power of the Franciscans to extract labor from the Indians and inaugurated a plan to
distribute mission lands. Venal public officials in charge of the distribution
granted the most valuable lands to themselves and their relatives.
The secularization processes, it was called, was so
restrictive that few ex-mission Indians were eligible for the distributed
lands. More significant still, the majority of surviving mission Indians were
not native to the areas of coastal missions. Most neophytes at this time had
been forced to relocate from their tribal domains and promptly returned to them
following their liberation.
Many of these returned exiles were faced with difficult
tasks of reconstructing their decimated communities in the wake of crippling
population declines. Furthermore their tribal lands had become transformed by
the introduction of vast herds of horses, cattle, sheep, goats and hogs that
destroyed the native flora, the primary source of native diet.
Wild game animals were likewise driven off by these new
animals. What developed from this new condition was the emergence of guerrilla
Indian bands made-up of former fugitive mission Indians and interior tribesmen
from villages devastated by official and unofficial Mexican paramilitary
attacks and slave hunting raids. Eventually a significant number of these
interior groups joined together to form new conglomerate tribes. These innovative
and resilient tribes quickly converted the anti-mission activities of their
members into systematic efforts to re-assert their sovereignty by widespread
and highly organized campaigns against Mexican ranchers and government
authority in general.
Vastly overestimating their power, Mexican authorities authorized additional 762 land grants by 1847. In reality the effectiveness of Indian stock raiders increased dramatically when American and Canadian fur trappers provided a lucrative market for purloined horses by the mid 1830's. Interior Mexican ranches were increasingly abandoned in the face of economic
ruin by native stock raiding activities.
Even Johann A. Sutter was reduced to begging the Mexican
government to buy his fort following a mauling at the hands of Miwok Indians
near the Calaveras in June of 1846.Despite these successes, a series of
murderous epidemics in the twilight years of the Mexican era severely reduced
the interior population.
For instance, in 1833 an American party of fur trappers introduced a murderous scourge of malaria into the Sacramento and San Joaquin River drainages. While traversing the epicenter of the plague, J. J. Warner reported, "From the head of the Sacramento to the great bend and slough
of the San Joaquin we did not see more than six or eight live Indians; while
large numbers of their skulls and dead bodies were seen under almost every
shade tree near the water, where the uninhabited and deserted villages had
been converted into graveyards."
In this tragedy more than 20,000 Central Valley Miwok, Yokuts, Wintun, and Maidu Indians perished. A new outbreak of small pox devastated Coast Miwok, Pomo, Wappo, and Wintun tribes. Approximately 2000 died in this 1837 epidemic originating from Fort Ross. By 1840 these and other murderous maladies had so thoroughly saturated the Indian population of Mexican California that diseases became endemic. Mexican forced labor and violence at the hands of the militia and paramilitary slave hunting parties account for a significant
amount of the population decline suffered by California Indians.
On the eve of the American take-over the aboriginal population of approximately 310,000 had been reduced to about 150,000. This gut wrenching 50% decline had occurred in just 77 years. The implications for survivors are largely a mute tale of suffering and grieving over the loss of a stunning number of children, parents and elders. What came next was
worse still.
THE AMERICAN INVASION
Alta California the poorly managed and badly neglected stepchild of Mexico was rapidly overwhelmed by a combination of aggressive Indian raids and the arrival of United States Army, Navy and Marine forces in the summer of 1846. Despite a seemingly irrational murderous attack on Sacramento River Maidu Indian villages by U.S. Army forces under the command of
John C. Fremont, the majority of California Indians involved in that struggle
aided the Americans as scouts, warrior-soldiers and wranglers.
When Mexican resistance collapsed in January of 1847,
thereafter Indian Affairs was administered by a succession of military
governors. Stock raiding Indians in the interior recommenced their depredations
when they learned Indian slavers such as Mariano Guadalupe Vallejo and Johann
A. Sutter had been appointed as Indian sub-agents. Military government's policy
was to suppress stock raiding and furthermore imposed draconian restrictions on
the free movement of Indians and required Indians to carry certificates of
employment.
THE GOLD RUSH
The discovery of gold in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada
at a sawmill construction site developed by Indian Agent Johann Sutter, ushered
in one of the darkest episodes of dispossession widespread sexual assault and
mass murder against the native people of California. Sutter immediately negotiated
a treaty with the chief of the Coloma Nisenan Tribe, which would have given a
three-year lease to lands surrounding the gold discovery site.
During those negotiations, the chief prophetically warned
Sutter that the yellow metal he so eagerly sought was, "very bad medicine.
It belonged to a demon who devoured all who searched for it". Eventually
the military governor refused to endorse Sutter's self-serving actions.
Within a year a hoard of 100,000 adventurers from all over the world descended upon the native peoples of California with catastrophic results. The entire state was scoured by gold seekers. Thinly spread government officials were overwhelmed by this unprecedented deluge of immigrants and all effective authority collapsed. Military authorities could
not prevent widespread desertion of soldiers and chaos reigned.
A virtual reign of terror enveloped tribesmen the mining districts. Wanton killings and violence against Indians resisting miners developed into a deadly pattern. An Oustemah Nisenan female named Betsy later recalled, "A life of ease and peace was interrupted when I was a little girl by the arrival of the white men. Each day the population increased and the Indians feared the invaders and great consternation prevailed .... as gold excitement advanced, we were moved again and again, each time in haste. Indian children.... when taken into town would blacken their faces with dirt so the newcomers would not steal them.... "
Numerous vigilante type paramilitary troops were established
whose principal occupation seems to have been to kill Indians and kidnap their
children. Groups such as the Humboldt Home Guard, the Eel River Minutemen and
the Placer Blades among others terrorized local Indians and caused the premier
19th century historian Hubert Howe Bancroft to describe them as follows.
"The California valley cannot grace her annals with a
single Indian war bordering on respectability. It can, however, boast a hundred
or two of as brutal butchering, on the part of our honest miners and brave
pioneers, as any area of equal extent in our republic......"
The handiwork of these well-armed death squads combined with
the widespread random killing of Indians by individual miners resulted in the
death of 100,000 Indians in the first two years of the gold rush. A staggering
loss of two thirds of the population. Nothing in American Indian history is
even remotely comparable to this massive orgy of theft and mass murder. Stunned
survivors now perhaps numbering fewer than 70,000 teetered near the brink of
total annihilation.
The newcomers sometimes met organized Indian resistance. In
1850 a Cupe–o chief named Antonio Garra Sr. organized local Southern California
Indians to resist an illegal tax imposed upon San Diego Indians by the county
sheriff. Sporadic attacks upon both Americans and some Mexicans by Garra's
followers resulted in a massive crackdown on Indian communities. Soon a rival
Cahuilla chief captured Garra and turned him over to the authorities who
promptly hung him and several of his followers.
In 1851 several mountain Miwok tribes offered armed
resistance to the hoard of miners overrunning their territory. When one tribe
destroyed a trading post owned by an American who kept at least 12 Indian
"wives" a paramilitary militia was formed and aggressively attacked
Indians throughout the southern mines area. Eventually this group calling
itself the "Mariposa Battalion" breached the unknown granite fortress
of the valley of Yosemite. A ruthless campaign against the Yosemite Indians
resulted in the capture of their Chief Teneya and a temporary exile to the San
Joaquin River "Indian Farm".
In reality these Indian campaigns were motivated by
rapacious greed of the miners to gain Indian lands and provide political
capitol for ambitious office seekers. Sadly both the state and federal
government eventually reimbursed the vast majority of these paramilitary forays
for expenses incurred. This is indeed a dreary story of subsidized murder on a
scale unequaled in all of this country's Indian wars.
TREATY MAKING AND TREATY REJECTION
In 1849 Washington sent two special emissaries to California
to report on the nature of Mexico's recognition of Indian land titles in
California. Neither spoke to a single Indian and eventually produced an
ambiguous and inaccurate report to the great disadvantage of the Indians.
Upon this misinformation, and in an attempt to stem the
unprecedented chaos and mass murder of the gold miners confrontation with the
California Indians, Congress authorized three federal officials to make
treaties with the California Indians.
Their purpose was to extinguish Indian land titles and
provide the Indians with territories that would be protected from encroachment
by non-Indians. They were given just $25,000 to accomplish this monumental
task.
Soon after their arrival in San Francisco in January of
1851, the enormous size of territory prompted the commissioners to split up and
negotiate treaties on their own. The reports and correspondence of the treaty
commissioners clearly demonstrate that the suspicious and reluctant Indians who
could be persuaded to attend the treaty meetings were only vaguely aware of its
purpose.
This can be attributed to the frequent problems of translators who often had to translate several Indian dialects into Spanish and again into English. Few if any of the Indians could understand English. The random manner in which the commissioners organized the meetings resulted in the majority of tribes not participating. Despite these crippling drawbacks, the
treaty process proceeded until January 5th of 1852.
In all,
eighteen treaties were negotiated. The treaties agreed to set aside certain
tracts of land for the signatory tribes. They additionally promised the
assistance of farmers, school teachers, blacksmiths, stock animals, seeds and
agricultural equipment, cloth and much more. In return the signatory tribes
promised to forever quitclaim to the United States their lands.
Just what specific lands being surrendered were not
specified. Anthropologists in the 20th century could only identify 67 tribes,
45 village names and 14 alternative spellings of tribal names. Eighteen groups
were unidentifiable. Despite the obvious fact that not all California Indian
tribes had been consulted or contacted they too would be bound by the
negotiations. Nevertheless, the federal government promised to reserve
7,466,000 acres of land to the dispossessed Indians,
An immediate outcry from an enraged public followed the
completion of the commissionerÕs task. It was revealed that the commissioners
had overspent their budget by a half a million dollars in the incredibly
inflated economy of gold rush California. Local newspapers orchestrated an
abusive campaign and local politicians echoed the fears of their compassionate
electorate that the treaty reserves might contain something valuable, like
gold.
Most Americans simply wanted the Indians removed to some
other territory or state. California's newly elected state senators provided
the final blow. On July 8, 1852 the Senate in executive session refused to
ratify the treaties. They were filed with an injunction of secrecy that was
finally removed in 1905!
Meanwhile, Congress had created a commission to validate
land tittles in California. The commission was required by law to both inform
the Indians that it would be necessary to file claims for their lands and
report upon the nature of these claims. Because no one bothered to inform the
Indians of these requirements, no claims were submitted.
Through this neat trick, the federal government
"legally" avoided the normally lengthy and duplicitous negotiations
over land sessions.The practical result was the complete dispossession of the
Indians in the eyes of the government. Despite this chicanery, several tribes
would violently and later legally contest these frauds to defend their
territory, homes and families.
From the native viewpoint, signatories of the treaties had
agreed to move to specific locations promised in the treaties. Yet such
attempts often met with violent attacks by miners and others opposed to the
very existence of Indians. Non-treaty groups simply endured the madness and
race hatred of those waging a merciless war against them. Most tribes did their
best to withdraw from all contact with the mayhem overwhelming them.
A HARSH STATE GOVERNMENT
The formation of the state government proved to be an official instrument of the oppressive mentality of the miner's militia. In Governor McDougall first address to the legislature he promised, "a war of extermination will continue to be waged between the races until the Indian race becomes extinct...."
Despite guarantees in the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo,
Indians were denied state citizenship, voting rights and more important still,
the right to testify in court. These acts effectively removed all legal redress
for native peoples and left them to the mercy of anyone who chose to sexual
assault, kidnap even murder them. Despite entering the union as a free state in
1850, the California legislature rapidly enacted a series of laws legalizing
Indian slavery.
One of the laws sanctioned an indenture system similar to
Mexican peonage in widespread practice throughout California prior to 1850. All
levels of state, county and local governments participated in this ugly
practice that evolved into a heartless policy of killing Indian parents and
kidnapping and indenturing the victims children. Indian youth could be enslaved
by the cruel act to the age of 30 for males and 25 for females. This barbarous
law was finally repealed four years after President Lincoln's emancipation
proclamation in 1863.
The federal government finally decided to establish an
Indian policy in California in 1854 when Edward F. Beale was appointed
Superintendent of Indian Affairs for California. Beale quickly established a
prototype Indian preserve within the boundaries of the Army's military reserve
in the Southern San Joaquin Valley, called Fort Tejon. The site was chosen
because of the continuing problem of local horse raiding by Southern California
Indians. Yokut, Gabrielino and Kitanemuk tribesmen were gathered together on
this barren 50,000-acre parcel call San Sebastian.
Beale's instruction from Washington authorized him to
establish four additional reserves with a $250,000 budget. Apparently Beale
squandered his entire allocation on less than 200 Indians at San Sebastian.
This action becomes comprehensible only when it is known that within a decade,
Beale wound up owning much of that short-lived reserve. His behavior in office
set the standard for decades of widespread corruption and incompetence that
distinguishes the Bureau of Indian Affairs in California and elsewhere.
Following Beale's removal from office in 1856, Col. T.J.
Henely established Indian Reserves on the Klamath River, Nome Lackee near
Colusa, Nome Cult (Round Valley) and the Mendocino Reserve at the mouth of the
Noyo River on the coast. The latter two were both located in Mendocino County.
These hastily organized communities provided little in the way of support or even minimal refuge for native peoples cajoled to move there. These unsurveyed reserves lacked game, suitable agricultural lands and water. They soon became overrun with white squatters who systematically corrupted the Indians and introduced an epidemic of venereal diseases.
More unsatisfactory still, were Indian Farms located on lands rented from
newcomers now holding legal title to said lands.
The Fresno and Kings River Indian Farms were established in
the south-eastern San Joaquin Valley along the rivers of the same name. Federal
records clearly show these farms provided only a handful of Indians homes, the
majority completely lacked cultivation, but they did provide paychecks for the
superintendentsÕ friends and political cronies. The majority of these early
reserves and Indian Farms were abandoned in the 1860's due to the state's
Indian slavery codes that allowed all able bodied males, females and even
children to be indentured to white citizens.
A great many reservation residents could not participate in
the agricultural and ranching programs because their labor "belonged"
to private state citizens. Frequently, federal and Indian agents themselves
indentured his wards for personal enrichment. Government records for this
period show that fewer than 3000 of the less than 70,000 surviving California
Indians received recognition let alone provisions for reservations. South of
the Tehachapi Mountains California Indians remained totally ignored by
Washington. So what were the vast majority of Indians doing during this period?
LATE 19TH CENTURY ADAPTATION AND RESISTANCE
The vast majority of California Indians struggled to survive
without government aid or recognition. Many on the verge of actual starvation
dispersed throughout their territories and sought to support themselves through
agriculture and ranch labor for the new "owners" of California. This
was a traditional pattern of behavior when drought and other natural
catastrophes struck.
Deprived of land and their life sustaining resources, they
were left with no other options. With a few notable exceptions, the mass murder
of the Gold Rush era diminished, as Indian victims became scarce and survivors
learned to avoid Americans whenever possible.
The great hardships of this adaptation were made bearable
with the development of a messianic cult movement called the Ghost Dance of
1870. In part triggered by the introduction of Christian missionary activities,
this new religious movement was pan-tribal in nature and obviously a response
to the massive population decline. The movement promised the return of dead
relatives and the disappearance of the oppressors. It was most desperately
embraced by those tribes who had most recently suffered great population
declines.
Despite lasting only a few years, it was fundamental in
revitalizing intra-tribal religious integration. In short, it provided hope for
the nearly hopeless situation Indian found themselves confronted with.
The last organized violent reaction to dispossession and federal Indian policy erupted between 1860-1872. The first was a series of Indian wars in Northwestern California. Here Yurok, Karok, Hupa and other tribes fought the increasingly paranoid and aggressive Americans who routinely murdered them, stole their children and burned their villages. Jack Norton,
a Hupa historian characterized the situation as a "deranged
frontier". Attempts to disarm Indians and continued kidnapping for sexual
slavery quickly led to violent resistance. In 1858, the militia established a
fort in the Hupa Valley to make war on the Wilkut and Chilula tribes. Many
members of those tribes had been captured and deported to the Mendocino
Reservation.
Frustrated by the stiff resistance of interior groups, the
militia found it easier to murder nearby inoffensive peaceful and non-hostile
Indians. The notorious Indian Island massacre in Humbolt Bay was the bitter
fruit of that race hatred. Eventually some Hupa Indians agreed to assist the
soldiers in hunting their hostile neighbors. Despite this defection, several
bands of Hupa joined the hostiles and effectively resisted until 1864 when they
surrendered. This led to the establishment of the Hupa Valley Reservation in
August of 1864.
Because both state and federal authorities seriously
underestimated the number of surviving California Indians, plans to remove all
Indians to the handful of reservations already established, proved impractical.
Several attempts to place multiple tribes on single reservations frequently
resulted in violence, mass murder and war. The Modoc war of 1872 was caused by
such a policy that insisted the Modocs be deported out of California to the
Klamath Reservation in Oregon. Driven twice from that reserve, a third attempt
to deport the Modocs back to Klamath resulted in a stunning war in 1872.
The Indian service removed the Konkow Indians of Chico and
the Atsugewi of Shasta County to the Round Valley Reservation in 1862.
Squatters overrunning the Reservation descended upon these unfortunate
tribesmen and murdered 45 of them. The mob justified its actions by claiming
the Indians might steal food from the squatters. Survivors fled in terror back
to Chico, only to be again removed to Round Valley sometime afterwards.
The BIA showed little interest in assisting such tribes. Those lucky enough to have reservations established in the aboriginal territories were understandably reluctant to share the scant advantages they enjoyed with newly arrived émigré tribes. Also true was the fact that no tribes desired to be relocated outside of their aboriginal territories. After all, each tribeÕs creation story emphasized the sacred nature of its own particular landscape. Tradition emphasized territorially and to stray from it required one to steal food resources from neighboring tribes. Non-Indians could not fathom the intensity and depth of the Indians spiritual attachment to their territories.
A steady population decline accompanied by widespread reports of destitution and hunger haunted those tribes without reserved lands. Despite hardship encountered, survival demanded innovation and adaptation. Being driven to the edge of extinction, Indians demonstrated again and again a strong will to survive. That determination not withstanding, the widespread kidnapping, slavery and violence took a frightful toll on tribesmen and their cultures. Leadership lineage's became scattered and displaced. Many ceremonies could no longer be held because access to sacred places was now denied. Cultural mandates to feed ceremonial guests could no longer be achieved by those who otherwise were able to hold public rituals. Finally, Christian missionaries gained control at many reservations under President Grant's Peace Policy of 1869. These folks were determined to destroy Indian culture and aboriginal belief systems that undergirded it.
The California superintendency attracted a succession of
special investigators caused by constant reports of corruption that reached
Washington. Special reports conducted in 1858, 1867 and 1883 clearly and
thoroughly document the corruption and inefficiency plaguing government programs
for Indians. President Grant's Peace Policy of 1869 inaugurated an era of
acculturation under duress. Policy makers in the government declared the only
path of salvation for surviving Indians would be Christianization, along with
the adaptation of private ownership of' property.
Once these twin goals were realized Indians would be
rewarded with citizenship and take their place among the lower classes with
other non-whites in American society. Reservation agents insisted their
residents join churches and cease practicing the old ways. The General
Allotment Act of 1887 forcibly divided reservation tribal lands, doling out
small parcels to individual Indians and their families. If the allotee built a
house, engaged in farming or ranching, sent his children to government Indian
schools and renounced his tribal allegiance and otherwise pleased the agent, he
would (after 25 years) receive title to his land and citizenship. Unlike tribal
lands, these parcels would become taxable. The program was inaugurated in California
in 1893.
By 1930 approximately 2,300 allotments had been carved out
of the tiny communal tribal reservation lands. Traditional Indians opposed the
detribalizing goals of allotment. The uneven and unequal distribution of
allotments was used by Indian agents to keep tribal populations divided and
politically impotent.
Nevertheless, considerable tribal resistance and pan-tribal
organizing developed in opposition to allotment. The program ground to a halt
in 1930 due to Indian opposition and failure of BIA to complete the necessary
paperwork. The law was repealed in 1934. Thousands of acres of California
Indian lands and millions of acres nationally were lost to
this destructive and ill-conceived policy.
PAN-INDIAN GROUPS, LANDLESS INDIANS, AND RANCHERIAS
Several hundred individual land allotments were distributed
to California Indians from public lands found principally in northern
California. Often times these were isolated havens from hostile neighbors. Many
were assigned to clusters of individuals who were related by kinship and are
likely core tribal members who otherwise hand no lands. The tribal communities
often held traditional ceremonies and participated in those of their more
fortunate reservation Indians.
Southern California Indians were finally provided with
recognition when several parcels of their former tribal domains were set aside
by executive order beginning in 1873 with the establishment of the Tule River
Indian Reservation. Fourteen Southern California Indian Reservations were set
aside by executive orders beginning in 1891 and amended in 1898. Unfortunately
Indians in both Orange and Los Angeles counties were excluded from land
distributions due in part to the value of coastal real estate. Nevertheless
small tribes from this area participated in pan Indian organizations.Reduced to
severe destitution the majority of Indians struggled to support their families
as landless laborers.
Only 6,536 Indians were recognized and living on reservations about the turn of the century. Every Indian who survived to see the dawn of the 20th century had witnessed great suffering and the irreplaceable loss of numerous grandparents, mothers, fathers and children. Some lineage's disappeared altogether. The nadir had been reached. Demographer S.F, Cook
determined the California Indian population declined to fewer than 16,000
individuals in 1900. This figure represents a gut wrenching descent from over
300,000 into a vortex of massive death in just 131 years of colonization! These
staggering losses prompted non-Indians of good will to assist Indian tribes in
efforts to secure lands for the still numerous landless Indians.
Several Indian reform groups blossomed before and after the
turn of the century. One of their earliest successes was a long legal effort to
prevent the Cupa Indians from being dispossessed of their ancestral village of
Warners Hot Springs. While losing the legal case, Cupa Indians and their allies
managed to secure lands on the nearby Pala Indian Reservation in San Diego
County. More important for the majority of landless Indians were the efforts of
the Northern California Indian Association that goaded the BIA into enumerating
landless Indians in 1905.
The result of the survey and political pressure from Indians and their friends resulted in federal actions creating 36 new reservations and Rancherias in 16 Northern California counties. Rancherias were very small parcels of land aimed at provided homesites only for small bands of landless Indians. They are all located in Northern California. Unfortunately the BIA's investigator failed to visit 12 other counties, thus ignoring the luckless Indians in those areas. Between 1933 and 1941 Congress authorized the enlargement of several Southern California reservations by
6492 acres. No rancherias or homesites were made available for landless
Southern California Indians.
Important developments occurred as a result of political activism on the part of both tribes and pan-Indian organizations from 1921 to the present. Beginning with the early efforts of the Indian Board of Cooperation, numerous California Indians self-help organizations and tribes pushed for a lawsuit over the failure of the United States to compensate the Indians of California for the loss of their aboriginal lands. Congress relented and passed the Jurisdictional Act of 1928. This legislation allowed the Indians to sue the federal government and use the state Attorney general's office to represent them.
Lacking control of their legal representative a controversial settlement was finally achieved in 1944. $17,053,941.98 was offered for the failure of the government to deliver the 18 reservations promised in treaty negotiations of 1851-2. Incredibly, the government decided to deduct all of its "costs" of providing reservations, supplies and even the salaries of
corrupt and do nothing Indians agents native peoples had endured for nearly a
century.
After another long battle, little more than 5 million
dollars were finally distributed on a per-capita basis to 36,095 California
Indians in 1951. A paltry $150. was distributed to surviving Indians. This
parsimonious and unfair settlement prompted California Indians to seek further
legal redress.
The efforts of California Indians to sue the federal government under the Jurisdictional Act of 1928 resulted in the creation of the federal Indian Claims Commission in 1946. This federal body allowed Indian groups to press for compensation to tribes over the theft of their lands in the 19th century. By August of 1951, twenty-three separate petitions had been filed by attorneys on behalf of tribes in California. After 20 years
of tortuous maneuvering all separate claims were consolidated into a single
case.
A compromise settlement of $29,100,000 was offered for
64,425,000 acres of acres of tribal territory. After deduction of attorney's
fees ($12,609,000) and the addition of interest and about half a million left
over from the first settlement the payment worked out to an offer of 47 cents
per acre! The purchase of public domain lands in California in 1850 was never
less than $1.50 per acre.
This outrageous offer offended many Indians who had pinned their hopes on a settlement that would provide seed money for desperately needed economic development. Despite bitter opposition by many of the original claimants, the federal government prepared a census of eligible Indians in preparation for an anticipated judgment. The BIA organized a series of
meetings to convince the litigants to accept the settlement. Eventually a
majority of the groups agreed, except the Pit River tribe.
They offered strong, vociferous and persistent opposition.
However, through questionable balloting, the government declared they had
accepted the offer in 1964. Nearly 65,000 California Indians were deemed
eligible to share in the settlement. Payments of little more than $600 per
person was distributed in 1968. What is of great significance here is the fact
that the entire claims activities were conducted outside of normal court
proceedings protected by the constitution. Thus Indians are the only class of
citizens in the United States who are denied constitutional protection of their
lands by extra-constitutional means.
TERMINATION
During the divisive and controversial land claims battle the BIA began to submit plans to end all services to California Indians and transfer all authority over federal Indian reservations to the State. This new policy, called Termination, was put into motion in 1951. Special agents were sent to prepare for the end of federal jurisdiction over tribal lands. At first the state was enthusiastic over the prospect of increasing its tax base with the anticipation of the privatization of federal trust properties. Termination became law in California under authority of the Rancheria
Act of 1958. This statute allowed tribes to vote on a plan to divide communal
tribal property into parcels to be distributed to its members. Distributees
would receive title to their lands and be free to sell it and be obliged to pay
property tax from that time forward. The BIA targeted the smallest, least
organized and most isolated tribes to persuade them to accept this plan for
cultural and tribal suicide.
Government personnel promised acceptance would result in
freedom and economic independence. They further made elaborate promises to
upgrade squalid housing, pave roads, build bridges, construct water projects
and even provide college scholarships in return for a vote to terminate.
Between 1958 and 1970 twenty-three rancherias and reservations were terminated.
Chronically high unemployment rates, low educational achievement and sometimes
emergency medical needs soon forced many to make loans on, or sell their lands.
Worse still, many BIA services like health, education were abruptly ended for
all Indians in the state.
Like the earlier allotment policy, the implementation of
termination set in motion a series of events that ultimately divested small
tribes of 10,037 acres of land, disrupted tribal institutions and traditions
and ultimately left these tribes more desperate, and impoverished than ever.
Termination failed miserably to improve the socioeconomic or political power of
the California Indians.
The occupation of Alcatraz Island in the San Francisco Bay, by nearly 100 American Indian College students in the fall of 1969 ushered in a new era of Indian affairs. A new generation of young, energetic and highly educated California Indians emerged during this period. Highly skeptical of the government they were committed to protecting tribal
sovereignty.
More important still, they found great value in tribal traditions. They encouraged traditional ceremonies, language retention and sought to remove impediments to the exercise of tribal religious practices. These developments paralleled a new generation of tribal leaders who would dynamically defend tribal rights. These activities made three things apparent; many California Indians were still landless, terminated tribes had been swindled, and some tribes had never been recognized by the federal government. However reservation, landless and unrecognized tribesmen all shared lives of desperate poverty and little hope for employment or economic development.
In recognition of the growing sophistication of California
Indians, the state legislature created the, Native American Heritage Commission
in 1978. This all-Indian commission works as a liaison between state, federal
and tribal governments. It has been successful in protecting Indian burials,
sacred places and providing access
to government lands to harvest native plants for ceremonial practices and
basketmaking.
To date 17 rancherias and reservations have reversed the disastrous termination process. Other tribes are currently pursuing legal avenues to reverse their termination status. Unrecognized tribes have vigorously pursued acknowledgment processes whose requirements are so impossibly demanding that many large tribes in Arizona and New Mexico could not today
meet such standards of cultural continuity. Nevertheless, the Acagchemem of San
Juan Capistrano the Muwekma of the San Francisco Bay area, and the Coast Miwok
of Marin County are close to federal recognition and acquiring a trust land
base.
Government developed economic development plans have a
history of nearly a century of total failure. Currently more than thirty
reservations and rancherias have established gaming businesses on their lands.
Some are highly successful while other are not. Some public opposition to these
activities seems to center around the fear that Indians may be cheated by their
business partners. Such fears smack of paternalism and ignore the reality that
few if any valuable resources can be found on Indian lands. Few private
investors have come forward to work with Indian tribes outside of the gaming
industry. With few choices, wise reservation leadership view gaming as an
interim step toward greater economic independence. The Viejas Band of Kumeyaay
Indians are the best example of how that dream can be achieved.
The amazing adaptive capabilities of California Indians have
demonstrated the resiliency and genius of these much misunderstood and hard
working tribes can achieve under the most unfavorable of circumstances. We
know, and our friends and counter parts in local and national governmental
agencies must understand that only through the exercise of our tribal
sovereignty can we successfully take our rightful place in our prosperous and
free nation. We enter the next century filled with optimism.
|